WICKED GOOD COOKIES
Baker's Choice Box
Couldn't load pickup availability
When you want the fun flavors—without the guesswork.
🍪 Cookies Included
2 dozen cookies total — 4 stacks (½-dozen each)
January Baker’s Choice Flavors:
-
🍪 Boston Chai Party – Chai-spiced cookie with warm, cozy notes
-
🍪 The Vermonter – Maple-forward, New England–inspired favorite
-
🍪 Salted Caramel – Sweet, buttery caramel finished with sea salt
-
🍪 HBD2U!! – Our classic birthday cake cookie with sprinkles
✨ Highlights
-
🎁 Packaged in a gift-ready box
-
💌 Add a gift message at checkout
-
📦 Four stacks for easy sharing (or freezing!)
-
👩🍳 Expertly curated by our bakers
-
🚫 No subscription required
Let the baker decide. Our Baker’s Choice Box is filled with the current month’s rotating flavors, thoughtfully curated and packed as four half-dozen stacks. Designed for variety and surprise (the good kind), this box is ideal for gifting, sharing, or sending a little cookie joy—no customization required.
Crafted with care, baked to irresistible perfection
Top Shelf Cookies only makes cookies, so we have be good at it. We have developed over 200 recipes in our ten years. Each recipe is carefully balanced, expertly combines high-quality and unique ingredients with well-crafted recipes. Every batch is crafted with care, attention to detail, and a passion for pushing the boundaries of cookie perfection.
Everyone loves Cookies!
-
HANDMADE
Our cookies are lovingly handcrafted in small batches using premium ingredients and artisanal techniques. Each bite delivers exceptional flavor and texture, brimming with homemade warmth and comfort.
-
INGREDIENTS YOU CAN PRONOUNCE
We use only high-quality, recognizable ingredients like rich butter, cage-free eggs, and real chocolate. Our commitment to wholesome ingredients means no artificial additives, just pure cookie goodness in every bite.
-
FAST SHIPPING
Free Shipping for orders over $50. We ship Tues-Sat
Top Shelf Cookies aren't your typical cookie, so it's no surprise we were founded in a less than typical manner. Heather started making cookies as a superstition and then made it her job. Over ten years later, Heather and her time are still crafting up new recipes with high quality and sometimes unusual ingredients!
Let customers speak for us
We received these cookies for Christmas. Dirty Water is the most delicious cookie I've ever tasted. It had a great combination of softness and crunch. My son-in-law also loved them.
This one is a great option as well. Can't go wrong with chocolate chips.
I love all of the flavors and so do the people I share them with! Thank you!
These are one of my favorite Christmas cookies!
By far these are the best Christmas cookies I have ever had. A new household favorite!
So delicious! Perfect gift to send or bring as a hostess gift.
I wait all year for these delectable cookies to be baking! Fabulous cookie with real blueberries in every bite. While Top Shelf cookies freeze very well, I have never attempted to feeze Enchanted Blueberry cookies because they are eaten almost as soon as arrive. A must try cookie for the holidays (and beyond)!
These are absolutely amazing, the ratio of mint and chocolate is perfect, reminds me of a mint oreo !
We gifted these to our families this year and sent ourselves a box just to make sure they were good :) They are *way beyond* good. So delicious, so fresh, and so special. Everyone who has received them so far has raved about them!
We give the cookie of the month membership as a gift and it is always loved and appreciated. Thankfully the recipient likes to share because the cookies are always so good. I like that they don't just send the same cookies over and over again. They are always coming up with fun new cookies to try that taste great.
I ordered the 6-month sampler as a birthday gift for a friend (one of those people who has everything). I haven’t tried them, but she says they are delicious. It turned out to be a wonderful gift, she loves getting a new box of different flavors each month. Also want to add a note about their great customer service people. Right after placing the order, I realized I had accidentally put my address instead of my friends as the ship-to. I emailed their Customer Service department to ask if I could get the address corrected. Within a few minutes, they notified me that my error was corrected. I highly recommend this company.
Two if by C….whats not to swoon over. Coconut, caramels create a sublime duo. We gobbled these up in no time & our guests kept asking for the recipe. I sent them your way.
